When Professionals Disagree: Who Speaks for the Learner?
Imagine that, after months of watching their child struggle, a family finally decides to seek professional help. Appointments are booked. Assessments are completed. Reports are written, and recommendations are made. For the first time in a long while, the parents feel they have direction. Then they visit another specialist. The report is glanced through, gently set aside, and a familiar statement follows: "I'd rather conduct my own assessment." Sometimes, that decision is entirely appropriate. Other times, it leaves parents confused, emotionally drained, and wondering whether they are starting the journey all over again. It raises an important question: When professionals disagree, who speaks for the learner? Why Another Assessment May Be Necessary Before we criticise professionals who request a fresh assessment, it is important to understand their responsibility. Assessment is more than administering tests. It involves selecting appropriate tools, interpreting evidence, ...